The Difference an Insert Can Make (Comparing Inserts in 3 Different Newspapers)

A coupon insert released the same day in three different newspapers can be a big difference!  In this post, I will show you the difference in three different newspapers in the area I live (North East Ohio).

The newspapers are 1.  The Akron Beacon Journal, 2. The Cleveland Plain Dealer, and 3. The Daily Record (Wooster, Ohio)

Just know that the Smart Source in one newspaper is very often different from the Smart Source in the next newspaper. If you live in an area where there is a high cost of living, you may get inserts that have higher value coupons than you may in areas where the cost of living is less.

The Akron Beacon Journal gives you the Smart Source coupon insert most Sundays. Once per month you may get the P&G insert as well (Proctor and Gamble). No Red Plum inserts.

The Cleveland Plain Dealer gives you the Smart Source coupon inserts most Sundays as well, and also no Red Plum coupon inserts. The coupons in this Smart Source are often at least halfway different than the ones in the Akron Beacon Journal’s Smart Source insert. In today’s insert, there were more pages in the Smart Source insert in the Plain Dealer than in the Beacon Journal and more different coupons (though more advertisements too). You may get the P&G inserts once monthly (or so) as well.

The (Wooster) Daily Record is my newspaper of choice, because you normally get the Smart Source every week along with the Red Plum insert and the monthly (or so) P&G inserts. So, you get more coupons in the Daily Record.

So here is the page-for-page comparison of the Smart Source Inserts in the three newspapers listed:

Comparison of 3 papers 01

They start out pretty similar…

Page 2:

Comparison of 3 papers 02

Page 3:

Comparison of 3 papers 03

 

Page 4:

Comparison of 3 papers 04

 

 

Page 5:

Comparison of 3 papers 05

 

Musselman’s Apple Sauce in the Plain Dealer, not in the other two

Page 6:

Comparison of 3 papers 06

Jell-O Pudding in the Plain Dealer, not in the other two

Page 7:

Comparison of 3 papers 07

Bertoli coupons in the Daily Record, not in the other two.

Page 8:

Comparison of 3 papers 08

Shampoo coupons in the Plain Dealer, not in the other two, Green cleaner in the Plain Dealer, not in the other two

Page 9:

Comparison of 3 papers 09

French’s marinade coupon in the Plain Dealer, not in the other two, Flora Probiotic coupon in the Plain Dealer, not in the other two

Page 10:

Comparison of 3 papers 10

Ace Bandage coupon in the Plain Dealer, not in the other two

Page 11:

Comparison of 3 papers 11

Finish Dishwashing Detergent in the Beacon Journal and Daily Record, but not in the Plain Dealer

Page 12:

Comparison of 3 papers 12

Pet food coupons in the Plain Dealer, not in the other two

Page 13:

Comparison of 3 papers 13

Edge Shave Gel coupons in the Plain Dealer, not in the other two

Page 14:

Comparison of 3 papers 14

That’s it for the Akron Beacon Journal…

Page 15:

Comparison of 3 papers 15

 

And that’s it for the Daily Record

Page 16:

Comparison of 3 papers 16

Arm & Hammer toothpaste in the Plain Dealer, not in the other two

Page 17:

Comparison of 3 papers 17

Dry Erase markers in the Plain Dealer, not in the other two

Page 18:

Comparison of 3 papers 18

Eye Care coupons not in the other two

Page 19:

Comparison of 3 papers 19

Page 20:

Comparison of 3 papers 20

 

Pen coupons, Greek Yogurt Cereal, and Flintstones Vitamins in the Plain Dealer, not in the other two

Page 21:

Comparison of 3 papers 21

Page 22:

Comparison of 3 papers 22

Coupon code for 50% off at One Stop Plus, not in the other two

Page 23:

Comparison of 3 papers 23

and lastly, Page 24:

Comparison of 3 papers 24

and my dog, Rudy, kept me company while doing this 🙂  :

Comparison of 3 papers 25

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

So you can see there are quite a few differences in the Smart Source released on the very same day in three different newspapers! So do your investigative work and find out which newspapers work the best for you and buy the most of those, and if you’re like me, you’ll buy a lesser amount of the next to best paper and maybe one of the other one (for the ads that are also different in that paper than the others) 🙂

So pay attention and get the most coupons that will work for your family each week!

 

Tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *